Here, There, and Back Again
Welcome to the chaotic, coffee-fueled corner of the internet where three middle-class Midwest moms spill the tea (and occasionally the wine) on all things dark, spooky, and downright hilarious.
We’re your new best friends who love diving deep into true crime cases, Missouri urban legends, haunted hotspots across the Ozarks, ghost stories that’ll make you sleep with the lights on, and every creepy paranormal encounter we can get our hands on. One minute we’re breaking down a chilling cold case or the latest Bigfoot sighting in the Show-Me State, and the next we’re ranking the best gas-station snacks or telling you about that one Tom Foolery night that ended with us trying (and failing) to summon a spirit with boxed wine and a Ouija board made of cardboard.
Expect unfiltered mom talk, zero pretense, plenty of cussing, and the occasional heavy topic (because life, loss, mental health ) handled with real heart. If you like your podcasts equal parts spooky, silly, and sisterhood, you’ve found your people.
Grab your favorite drink, lock the doors, and come hang out with three Midwest mamas who refuse to act their age. New episodes every week — because the ghosts (and the group chat) never sleep.
🔪👻🍷
Contact
Email: herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
Tom Foolery Form: https://form.jotform.com/250725383034049
Supernatural Form:https://form.jotform.com/250726134220041
Episodes
Jul 9, 2026
Jul 9, 2026
21 min
Tarah flies solo as she covers the case of Johnny Lee Wilson, a 20 year man who was convicted of killing 79 year old Pauline Martz back in 1987. This case isn't so straightforward, and not only does it end up on Unsolved Mysteries but 9 years after his conviction, Missouri's Governor ended up giving him a full pardon.
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
True Crime
https://form.jotform.com/260304229382048
Links
https://unsolvedmysteries.fandom.com/wiki/Johnny_Lee_Wilson
https://robertperske.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/Johnny_Wilson_Did_Not_Kill_Anybody.pd
f
Jul 1, 2026
Jul 1, 2026
1 hr 43 min
Tarah has Brandi back over as they discuss who they blame for the current state of Missouri's education.
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
Serious(ish)
https://form.jotform.com/260304472640045
Jun 25, 2026
Jun 25, 2026
49 min
Tarah tells Adi about how when researching for another story, AI suggested that she look into the story surrounding Stacy Simpson, a 14 year old who was convicted and later acquitted for the murder of her mother in 1986. This story takes some unexpected turns that leaves both of them with so many questions.
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
True Crime
https://form.jotform.com/260304229382048
Links
https://batescountynewswire.blogspot.com/2025/09/history-of-bates-county-murder-of-janet.html
https://law.justia.com/cases/missouri/court-of-appeals/1992/15001-0.html
Jun 17, 2026
Jun 17, 2026
49 min
Ashley tells the heartbreaking true events of extreme abuse that inspired the disturbing movie The Girl Next Door and Steph tells the real story behind the movie Foxcatcher.
True Crime
https://form.jotform.com/260304229382048
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
Links
legalnews.com
indyencyclopedia.org
https://allthatsinteresting.com/john-du-pont-dave-schultz
Jun 10, 2026
Jun 10, 2026
47 min
From kids to chickens to golf, Tarah, Ashley, and Steph talk about all the little dramatic things going on in their lives.
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
Tom Foolery
https://form.jotform.com/260304430593046
Jun 3, 2026
Jun 3, 2026
56 min
The girls cover the mysteries of Dear David, Brian Schaffer, Flight 19, and The Dancing Plague.
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
True Crime
https://form.jotform.com/260304229382048
May 27, 2026
May 27, 2026
58 min
Victoria and Tarah finish their staff lounge conspiracy conversation that involve the weird people of Hollywood, Rap music being a PSYOP, and other completely random thoughts.
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
True Crime
https://form.jotform.com/260304229382048
May 20, 2026
May 20, 2026
43 min
The girls tell the supernatural rumors that surround the sets of the movies The Poltergeist and The Crow.
Supernaturalhttps://form.jotform.com/260303909758059
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
May 13, 2026
May 13, 2026
1 hr 12 min
Victoria and I convince ourselves that the increase in tick born illnesses in Missouri are not natural.
Email
Form
Data Center Cooling
Data Center Electric Bills
Hawley and Kennedy
May 6, 2026
May 6, 2026
44 min
Steph and I will be scaring Ashley when we tell her the true events behind the movies The Possession and The Entity.
Email
herethereandbackagain25@gmail.com
Supernatural
https://form.jotform.com/260303909758059